Index: [thread] [date] [subject] [author]
  From: <djg2120@columbia.edu>
  To  : <cpc@emoglen.law.columbia.edu>
  Date: Thu, 02 Mar 2006 12:36:24 -0500

Search Engines Are At the Center Of Privacy Debate

Search Engines Are At the Center Of Privacy Debate

The more user information gathered by Google, Yahoo and Microsoft
MSN, the more often they will become the targets of governments.

InternetWeek

Mar 1, 2006 03:07 AM

At the center of the square off over the access to private personal
data online -- a much publicized debate that extends from Beijing
to Washington -- stands an uncertain arbiter: the search engine.

The companies that operate the most popular search engines --
Google, Yahoo and Microsoft -- are making decisions about how the
information they collect about user behavior should be protected,
in some cases from the eyes of governments that want to take a
closer look but lack a clear legal right to do so.

"Search engines are the future of [that] debate," says Timothy Wu, a
Columbia Law School professor specializing in telecommunications
law, copyright, and international trade. "Questions about policy
ultimately are going to be handled by search engines -- whether we
live in a more or less government-controlled country."

As the collection and storage of data becomes an industry of its
own, the availability of the information "is a temptation for the
government," says Sherwin Siy, staff counsel at the Electronic
Privacy Information Center, a nonprofit public interest group. He,
Wu and others spoke Tuesday in a panel discussion at the Search
Engine Strategies conference in New York City.

And when governments -- not just in the United States, but around
the world -- want information about their citizens, "Search engines
are first places they go," says Wu, who is also the co-author of a
new book, "Who Controls the Internet."

Recently, Google has resisted a subpoena by the Justice Department
to turn over search query data, while in China, Yahoo has complied
with government requests for data that have led to the imprisonment
of at least three people.

In the past year, search engines have unveiled new features in their
services that are based on an individual's history of online
inquiries. Google's Personalized Search, for example, still in beta
after launching last June, orders results based on what a user has
sought out in the past.

Searches conducted on a user-downloaded toolbar, offered by all the
major U.S. portals, collect more information than a search engine
normally would.

Ramez Naam, group program manager for Microsoft Corp.'s MSN Search,
believes that consumers are not as concerned about the security of
information related to their Internet searches as they are with
fighting computer viruses, for which they often purchase extra
software protection.

"Privacy is not something that people are saying this is priority
one, you have to have this," he says. Anonymous surfing software is
available from companies such as Anonymizer, but "few people are so
motivated that they would install this."

Microsoft is working to make its privacy agreements more
comprehensible for the average user, he says.

While Amazon.com has shown that personalization can be a valuable
service for consumers when they're shopping, "in the search engine
world we've not yet demonstrated this is a great feature."

"We're highly motivated to figure out what we can do to give people
the privacy they need and the services on top of that," Naam says.
"There's certainly an opportunity to provide value-add to customers
and make more money."

A key public policy question for the future will be how easily
search engines and future browser software accommodate individuals
who wish to protect their identity while using the Internet, Wu
says.

"Search engines can't help but take a political stance," he says.
"When they make a decision to put an Anonymizer in software,
they're making a decision."
http://www.informationweek.com/news/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=181401639
_______
Daniel Grimm
djg2120@columbia.edu


-----------------------------------------------------------------
Computers, Privacy, and the Constitution mailing list



Index: [thread] [date] [subject] [author]