Law in Contemporary Society

View   r6  >  r5  ...
JenniferBurke-FirstPaper 6 - 23 Mar 2008 - Main.EbenMoglen
Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="FirstPaper%25"
Line: 19 to 19
 

America in a World Context

Changed:
<
<
Benjamin Franklin said, “better that one hundred guilty men go free than one innocent person should suffer.” Feliks Dzerzhinsky, founder of the Soviet Secret police commanded “better to execute ten innocent men than to leave one guilty man alive.| Source. Franklin’s words epitomize the criminal justice system that America believes itself to have, one that is just and democratic. Statements like Dzerzhinsky’s are used as examples of “other” governments, which stand for injustice and oppression. Thurman Arnold says that social creeds, like justice and democracy, mean nothing outside of the institutions which they are attached to | Works Cited. America’s use of the death penalty exemplifies this. While statement’s like Franklin’s purport the United States to be fair and democratic, the facts show that capital punishment resounds in injustice. In a nation that often separates “us,” systems upholding similar values, from “them,” systems to be feared or conquered, America’s utilization of capital punishment puts the US in the latter category.
>
>
Benjamin Franklin said, “better that one hundred guilty men go free than one innocent person should suffer.”

  • Benjamin Franklin didn't "say" it if "say" means originate. franklin had it from Blackstone, who had it from Sergeant Hawkins who had it, probably, from Adam's off ox.

Feliks Dzerzhinsky, founder of the Soviet Secret police commanded “better to execute ten innocent men than to leave one guilty man alive.| Source.

  • Volokh has no source for this, as you may have noticed, and although he knows you're wrong about Franklin he can't be bothered to get the Blackstone reference right, as I found when I checked him. Don't you bother to check your own sources? Awarding Volokh any credibility is stupid in the first place, but even if he had lots of credibility you shouldn't cite what you haven't seen.

Franklin’s words epitomize the criminal justice system that America believes itself to have, one that is just and democratic. Statements like Dzerzhinsky’s are used as examples of “other” governments, which stand for injustice and oppression. Thurman Arnold says that social creeds, like justice and democracy, mean nothing outside of the institutions which they are attached to | Works Cited. America’s use of the death penalty exemplifies this. While statement’s like Franklin’s purport the United States to be fair and democratic, the facts show that capital punishment resounds in injustice. In a nation that often separates “us,” systems upholding similar values, from “them,” systems to be feared or conquered, America’s utilization of capital punishment puts the US in the latter category.

 The United States is the only western country to use capital punishment, and according to Amnesty International, America had the sixth highest execution rate in 2006 behind countries America identifies as enemies: Iran and Iraq | Source. Recently, the United States announced its decision to seek death for 9/11 detainees. Knowing that this decision will be questioned by countries the United States considers part of the “us,” the government sent a memo to its embassies comparing the 9/11 trials to Nuremberg as justification. While America asserts itself as a just and free democracy, its use of capital punishment actually separates it from its allies, who find capital punishment to be contradictory to the values America claims to uphold.
Line: 48 to 56
 
Changed:
<
<
>
>
  • Aside from the inaccuracies, what's new here? You wrote a cliche version of the abolitionist pamphlet that we've both read hundreds if not thousands of times. Which part represented an idea you hadn't seen before?
 

Works Cited


Revision 6r6 - 23 Mar 2008 - 19:27:23 - EbenMoglen
Revision 5r5 - 14 Feb 2008 - 19:53:58 - JenniferBurke
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform.
All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
All material marked as authored by Eben Moglen is available under the license terms CC-BY-SA version 4.
Syndicate this site RSSATOM