Law in Contemporary Society

View   r41  >  r40  ...
RaceVClass 41 - 11 Apr 2012 - Main.MeaganBurrows
Line: 1 to 1
 I realize this is going to be a pretty damn controversial post, but I feel compelled to speak on the subject. I sometimes become concerned that classism becomes too easily conflated with racism in our world.

There's many draws to calling a certain policy racist:

Line: 336 to 336
 In the interest of bringing outside reading into the conversation, Kent Russell's American Juggalo is a great, quick journalistic take on race and class in America. Its focus is more on how the race/class discussion in America alienates poor whites (who, using Michelle's figures, make up ~10% of an increasingly economically-static America), but I think that is perhaps a more interesting -- and valuable, with respect to solving the very real problem of rural poverty in America -- discussion than how those of us who are white CLS students feel in this discussion. -- MatthewCollins - 11 Apr 2012
Changed:
<
<
I can’t speak for others (although I imagine that Toma and Kipp share my sentiments) but I am in no way attempting to shirk complicity in the perpetuation of ‘white supremacy’. I just don’t think that all of this complicity can be placed on ‘white people’ as a race, as I feel it sometimes - though not always - is by those attempting to challenge it. We are all complicit in the system, regardless of skin color. To borrow your example regarding rape and the sexualization of women, I – as woman – don’t point to ‘men’ and blame them for the structural inequalities still remaining in our political, legal and social institutions and the social framework that perpetuates the subjugation of women. As a woman, I also accept complicity in perpetuating the system. Women themselves are often just as complicit as men in proliferating stereotypes and – whether advertently or not – allow the system to maintain itself. This is one of the problems I have with some of the rhetoric in certain feminist literature. It posits men as ‘the other’ and as women on the defensive in an ‘us against them’ framework. I do believe that men need to acknowledge their complicity, but women must also do so. I believe we must acknowledge that we are all complicit, and recognize that this complicity is what unites us and that we must work together to institute change. I don’t mean to say that African Americans are in some way responsible for or the cause of white supremacy, or that they are refusing to acknowledge their role in the system, or that they uniformly demonize white people. I only argue that privilege and focus should be placed on what unites us as individuals all living under the same structurally unequal system and that we all have an interest in dismantling it. Living within a ‘white supremacist’ society and with social racism is destructive and to the detriment of all races. I think that if we abandon racial distinctions and classifications that have historically been used and continue to be used by political forces to perpetuate difference and 'otherness' and cloud or distort the similarities that unite us, we will all be better off.
>
>
I can’t speak for others (although I imagine that Toma and Kipp share my sentiments) but I am in no way attempting to shirk complicity in the perpetuation of ‘white supremacy’. I just don’t think that all of this complicity can be placed on ‘white people’ as a race, as I feel it sometimes - though not always - is by those attempting to challenge it. We are all complicit in the system, regardless of skin color.

To borrow your example regarding rape and the sexualization of women, I – as woman – don’t point to ‘men’ and blame them for the structural inequalities still remaining in our political, legal and social institutions and the social framework that perpetuates the subjugation of women. As a woman, I also accept complicity in perpetuating the system. Women themselves are often just as complicit as men in proliferating stereotypes and – whether advertently or not – allow the system to maintain itself. This is one of the problems I have with some of the rhetoric in certain feminist literature. It posits men as ‘the other’ and women as on the defensive in an ‘us against them’ framework. I do believe that men need to acknowledge their complicity, but women must also do so. I believe we must acknowledge that we are all complicit, and recognize that this complicity is what unites us and that we must work together to institute change.

I don’t mean to say that African Americans are in some way responsible for or the cause of white supremacy, or that they are refusing to acknowledge their role in the system, or that they uniformly demonize white people. I only argue that privilege and focus should be placed on what unites us as individuals all living under the same structurally unequal system and that we all have an interest in dismantling it. Living within a ‘white supremacist’ society and with social racism is destructive and to the detriment of all races. I think that if we abandon racial distinctions and classifications that have historically been used and continue to be used by political forces to perpetuate difference and 'otherness' and cloud or distort the similarities that unite us, we will all be better off.

 -- MeaganBurrows - 11 Apr 2012

Revision 41r41 - 11 Apr 2012 - 20:11:36 - MeaganBurrows
Revision 40r40 - 11 Apr 2012 - 20:11:23 - MatthewCollins
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform.
All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
All material marked as authored by Eben Moglen is available under the license terms CC-BY-SA version 4.
Syndicate this site RSSATOM