Should I approach editing as if I were an editor for someone who was asking me to make revisions before they submitted something as his/her own? I am unsure how much liberty to take with the rewrite and what Eben is looking for. Is it what I consider to be a good paper? A better version of the author's paper? What if I disagree with my author's argument, am I meant to make my own using his/her underlying premises?

-- NonaFarahnik - 19 Apr 2010